Home Contact Us Maps Links The Constitution Marikana
| More

SAHRC welcomes Supreme Court judgment on the delivery of textbooks in Limpopo

2nd December 2015

Attention: Editors and Reporters

The South African Human Rights Commission (Commission) welcomes the judgment handed down by the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) on 2 December 2015 in the case of Minister of Basic Education and others vs Basic Education for All and others, and congratulates Section 27 in leading the process of initiating proceedings in this matter.

Dismissing the appeal by the Department of Basic Education and the Limpopo Provincial Department of Basic Education (DBE) the SCA held that “the law is clear…The DBE is obliged to provide a textbook to every learner to ensure compliance with s 29(1)(a) of the Constitution. We must guard against those who are most vulnerable. In this case we are dealing with the rural poor and with children. They are deserving of Constitutional protection."

In 2012, the High Court had in its judgment declared that: (a) the appellants’ failure to have delivered prescribed textbooks before the commencement of the teaching was a violation of learners’ rights to basic education, equality and dignity, and (b) ordered the Department of Basic Education to provide every learner with prescribed textbooks before the commencement of the academic year.

The Commission participated in both the High Court and the SCA proceedings. The Commission’s participation was motivated by its constitutional and statutory mandate to promote the respect, protection and monitoring of human rights in South Africa. The Commission had earlier investigated and convened hearings on the procurement and delivery of textbooks nationally.

The judgment reaffirms that the state has an obligation to realise the right to basic education and as such, textbooks are indispensable and play an important role in the realisation of the right. Furthermore, that the rights to basic education and equality are individual rights to which every learner is entitled. Education is a vehicle for the fulfilment of the right to equality. The judgment further confirms that the right to basic education is not subject to progressive realisation but should receive immediate attention.

The Commission notes that the SCA’s overwhelmingly approved the submissions proffered by the Commission and Basic Education for All (BEFA), which put across similar arguments. Delivering its judgment, the SCA bemoaned the DBE’s planning and preparedness to implement a new curriculum. The SCA confirmed the order granted by the Judge Kollapen in the High Court in 2012 wherein the judge had noted that the failure to provide textbooks to some learners in Limpopo affected learners adversely. Judge Kollapen had further noted that the failure to deliver books was a violation of the learners’ rights to, amongst others, basic education, equality and dignity. The SCA also noted the DBE’s non-compliance with the orders High Court order.

The Commission welcomes the SCA’s forward looking judgment in respect of section 29(1)(a) of the Constitution. The Commission views this judgment as a victory for the learners in public schools, in particular those in poor and rural communities. The judgment is an affirmation that literacy, and education in general, is a basic human right and a means to the realisation of other rights.

The Commission urges the DBE to comply with the order of the SCA by ensuring that each and every learner is provided with the necessary materials in order for them to realise their right to a basic education.


Issued by the SA Human Rights Commission
Isaac Mangena

For comments email info@sahrc.org.za [Back]

- See more at: http://www.justice.gov.za/legislation/constitution/index.html#sthash.vQme5ODl.dpuf

The South African Constitution

The Commission is available on social media

SAHRC TWITTER.jpg One.jpg @SAHRCommission

Facebook-Icon.jpg SA Human Rights Commission

YOU1.png SAHRC 1

To lodge a human rights violation complaint, click here.

or Call 011 877 3600
e-mail: complaints@sahrc.org.za

Provincial contact details are available here


PAIA section 14 Manual.jpg


SAHRC launches investigation into allegations of racism at University of the Free State
SAHRC finalizing report on complaints against King Goodwill Zwelithini
SAHRC response to ANC petition on racism
International Disability Day – SAHRC calls for employers to do more
SAHRC welcomes Supreme Court judgment on the delivery of textbooks in Limpopo


Pfanelo January Edition

Upcoming Events

  • 20 year Anniversary Celebration


Report any fraudulent and/or unethical behavior taking place in the Commission anonymously to the SAHRC Tip-offs Line.

FreeCall: 0800 222 365
Email: sahrc@tip-offs.com
FreeFax: 0800 00 77 88
FreePost: KZN 138, Umhlanga Rocks 4320
Website: www.tip-offs.com

Independently managed by the Office of the Public Service Commission.


SAHRC Programmes

Since its establishment, the SAHRC has dedicated itself to:
•  Raising awareness;
•  Monitoring and assessment;
•  Education and training
•  Addressing human rights violations

How can the SAHRC help?

The SAHRC promotes, protects and monitors human rights in South Africa. It also has a specific responsibility to promote and monitor the implemen-
tation of PAIA.


08 March – International Women’s Day
21 March - Human Rights Day
27 April – Freedom day
1 May - Workers day
03 May – World Press Freedom Day

[See more]