Home Contact Us Maps Links The Constitution Marikana
| More

Statement delivered by Commissioner Sandi Baai at the news briefing to release the report of the investigation into the complaint by Agri-SA against the Minister of Human Settlements
Thursday, 25 August 2011

On behalf of the Commission, I would like to thank you for responding to our invitation to attend this media briefing.

On the 08th of February 2010, the Commission received a complaint from Agri-SA against the Minister of Human Settlements, Mr Tokyo Sexwale, for the remarks he made during an interview on the SABC - Morning Live Programme, on the 03rd of November 2009.

THE COMPLAINT

During the interview the Minister made the following remarks: “….the growing number of squatter camps in South Africa is caused by people who are kicked out by very, very evil farmers from the farms, fearful of the fact that laws say that you got to provide these people with security of comfort….”

The complaint also related to the “Beeld” quote newspaper of the 29th of January 2010, wherein the Minister is reported to have told the Parliamentary Portfolio Committee on Human Settlements on the 28th of January 2010 that “baie van die mense wat hulle nou in plakkerskampe bevind is daar omdat baie boere miljoene swart mense van hulle plase afgejaag het”.

Agri-SA argued that the Minister’s utterances were accusations which were or can usually not be substantiated and were therefore harmful to the image of the commercial farming community.

FINDINGS

Following our perusal of Section 09 and 16 of the Constitution, as well as Section 10, read with Section 12 of the Promotion of Equality and Prevention of Unfair Discrimination Act 4 of 2000, including case law, we came to the conclusion that the Minister was merely expressing an opinion, without presenting facts, on some of what he perceived as the causes of the increase in squatter camps in the country.

Consequently, we therefore find that the Minister’s speech cannot reasonably be construed to have had the intention to make the members of the farming community feel marginalised, alienated or under attack.

We would like to point out that even though we find that the Minister’s utterances do not amount to hate or harmful speech, we are however of the view they were unpalatable.

In terms of legislation, advocacy of hatred does not rise to the level of hate speech unless there is also incitement to cause harm. The speech must be intended to incite or produce imminent action and must be likely to incite or produce such action. “Incited” should be taken to mean ‘directed at’ or ‘intended’.

There must be a causal connection between the advocacy of hatred based on one of the listed grounds and the harm that is caused. The weaker the proximity or causal link, the less likely it is that the expression would be deemed to be hate speech. There must be a real likelihood that the expression causes harm before it can be deemed to be hate speech.

The Commission is of the view that the Minister made the utterances in the context of an interview on challenges faced by the National Ministry of Human Settlements and specifically in responding to a question on the causes of the many squatter camps in South Africa.

It is important to note that according to the recording of the interview that the Minister specifically mentions that people in farms are being kicked out of farms by certain very, very evil farmers. Therefore considered in context, the Minister’s utterances are not general and cannot be said to have been aimed at all farmers. Furthermore, that “baie van die mense wat hulle nou in plakkerskampe bevind is daar omdat baie boere miljoene swart mense van hulle plase afgejaag het” may merely be inaccurate or unsubstantiated.

Based on the context of the Minister’s utterances outlined above, it is the Commission’s view that whilst negative utterances or allegations, made without presenting any proof, may have the potential to be inaccurate and irresponsible, the Minister’s utterances were not made with the intention to harm identifiable and or commercial farmers in general in the country.

The Commission is further of the view that the substantiation (or lack thereof) of the said utterances by the Minister would not cause the utterances to amount to a violation of any of the fundamental human rights enshrined in the Constitution.

RECOMMENDATIONS

In light of our findings, we therefore recommend that, in general, all South Africans, and in particular those in public office or in decision making positions, should refrain from making utterances or statements, and expressing opinions which have the potential to be unpalatable and/or offensive to others. 

Instead these officials should use such public platforms to communicate in a manner that respects and upholds the rights of others, promotes the values of the Constitution and contributes towards the building of a nation that is united in its diversity.

I thank you.

For comments email info@sahrc.org.za [Back]



- See more at: http://www.justice.gov.za/legislation/constitution/index.html#sthash.vQme5ODl.dpuf

The South African Constitution

The Commission is available on social media

SAHRC TWITTER.jpg One.jpg @SAHRCommission

Facebook-Icon.jpg SA Human Rights Commission

YOU1.png SAHRC 1


To lodge a human rights violation complaint, click here.

or Call 011 877 3600
e-mail: complaints@sahrc.org.za

Provincial contact details are available here

 



PAIA section 14 Manual.jpg


MEDIA STATEMENTS

SAHRC launches investigation into allegations of racism at University of the Free State
SAHRC finalizing report on complaints against King Goodwill Zwelithini
SAHRC response to ANC petition on racism
International Disability Day – SAHRC calls for employers to do more
SAHRC welcomes Supreme Court judgment on the delivery of textbooks in Limpopo


SAHRC NEWSLETTER

Pfanelo January Edition


Upcoming Events

  • 20 year Anniversary Celebration

 

Report any fraudulent and/or unethical behavior taking place in the Commission anonymously to the SAHRC Tip-offs Line.

FreeCall: 0800 222 365
Email: sahrc@tip-offs.com
FreeFax: 0800 00 77 88
FreePost: KZN 138, Umhlanga Rocks 4320
Website: www.tip-offs.com

Independently managed by the Office of the Public Service Commission.



 

SAHRC Programmes

Since its establishment, the SAHRC has dedicated itself to:
•  Raising awareness;
•  Monitoring and assessment;
•  Education and training
•  Addressing human rights violations

How can the SAHRC help?

The SAHRC promotes, protects and monitors human rights in South Africa. It also has a specific responsibility to promote and monitor the implemen-
tation of PAIA.

Calendar

08 March – International Women’s Day
21 March - Human Rights Day
27 April – Freedom day
1 May - Workers day
03 May – World Press Freedom Day

[See more]