Home Contact Us Maps Links The Constitution Marikana
| More
SAHRC to appeal judgment of the Lydenburg Equality Magistrate Court
Wednesday, 03 August 2011

The Commission will appear before the North Gauteng High Court to appeal the judgment of the Lydenburg Equality Magistrate Court which dismissed its complaint regarding allegations of hate speech and the use of insulting language.

This matter relates to a complaint which was lodged with the Commission by the complainant, Mr Letswano Johannes Baloyi, who alleged that the respondent, Mr Deon Labuschagne, referred to him using the K-word during an argument on a farm on 07 December 2007. After its receipt of the complaint the Commission proceeded to lodge papers with the Equality Court on his behalf in terms of the Equality Act.

The respondent, who is the farm owner, is alleged to have been angry after Mr Baloyi, who is a tenant on the farm, erected a tent for a wedding allegedly without the respondent’s consent.

The Equality Court, however, proceeded to dismiss this matter after the respondent pointed out during the proceedings that an affidavit which contained negative allegations concerning him had been placed in the court file without being served on or provided to him ahead of the trial. This was however denied by the Commission.

The court further proceeded to grant an order of punitive cost de bonis propiis against the Commission citing that the content of the affidavit which was prepared by the complainant’s witness would prejudice the respondent and render the trial unfair.

In its appeal papers the Commission argues that by dismissing this matter without even providing the Commission with the opportunity to argue its merits, the court did not apply its mind properly and acted unfairly.

The Commission is of the view that there is no reason why the documents the complainant considered relevant could not be provided accordingly and that the clerk of the Equality Court could have provided the documents to the respondent, but apparently did not do so.

Furthermore, the mere presence of the documents in the court file did not negatively affect the proceedings and the court should have merely directed that a copy be provided to the respondent with sufficient time being afforded to the respondent to prepare for the proceedings, and then proceed to hear this matter on the day or at a future date.

The Commission is asking the High Court to set aside the judgment of the Equality Court and refer this matter back to be fully argued and determined after hearing all the admissible evidence and submissions from all parties.

This matter is scheduled to be heard on Friday, 05 August 2011 at 10:00 in Court no: 4-F

ENDS

For comments email info@sahrc.org.za [Back]



- See more at: http://www.justice.gov.za/legislation/constitution/index.html#sthash.vQme5ODl.dpuf

The South African Constitution

The Commission is available on social media

SAHRC TWITTER.jpg One.jpg @SAHRCommission

Facebook-Icon.jpg SA Human Rights Commission

YOU1.png SAHRC 1


To lodge a human rights violation complaint, click here.

or Call 011 877 3600
e-mail: complaints@sahrc.org.za

Provincial contact details are available here

 



PAIA section 14 Manual.jpg


MEDIA STATEMENTS

SAHRC launches investigation into allegations of racism at University of the Free State
SAHRC finalizing report on complaints against King Goodwill Zwelithini
SAHRC response to ANC petition on racism
International Disability Day – SAHRC calls for employers to do more
SAHRC welcomes Supreme Court judgment on the delivery of textbooks in Limpopo


SAHRC NEWSLETTER

Pfanelo January Edition


Upcoming Events

  • 20 year Anniversary Celebration

 

Report any fraudulent and/or unethical behavior taking place in the Commission anonymously to the SAHRC Tip-offs Line.

FreeCall: 0800 222 365
Email: sahrc@tip-offs.com
FreeFax: 0800 00 77 88
FreePost: KZN 138, Umhlanga Rocks 4320
Website: www.tip-offs.com

Independently managed by the Office of the Public Service Commission.



 

SAHRC Programmes

Since its establishment, the SAHRC has dedicated itself to:
•  Raising awareness;
•  Monitoring and assessment;
•  Education and training
•  Addressing human rights violations

How can the SAHRC help?

The SAHRC promotes, protects and monitors human rights in South Africa. It also has a specific responsibility to promote and monitor the implemen-
tation of PAIA.

Calendar

08 March – International Women’s Day
21 March - Human Rights Day
27 April – Freedom day
1 May - Workers day
03 May – World Press Freedom Day

[See more]